Acm conference on programming language design and implementation, pages 425434, san diego, ca, june, 2007. With modern, complex softwareintensive systems, quality requirements may even vary depending on changes to deployment scenario and end users. Design and implementation, tse 2001 extended journal. However, these principles are just partially applied to the subsequent objectoriented implementation, often due to efficienc y constraints, yielding to a gap between design and implementation. Murphy, member, ieee computer society, david notkin, senior member, ieee, and kevin j. Multiobjective reconstruction of software architecture. Bridging the gap between design and implementation designing a programme for scale and implementing it on the ground can be two different things altogether. Murphy, member, ieee computer society, david notkin, senior. Bridging the gap between source and highlevel models article pdf available in acm sigsoft software engineering notes 20 may 1996 with 203 reads how we measure reads. Bridge pattern can be used to avoid the binding between abstraction and implementation and to select the implementation at run time. The architectural drift problem defines the discrepancy between the architecture description and the resulting implementation. Jun 01, 20 read incremental reflexion analysis, journal of software.
Polymetric viewsa lightweight visual approach to reverse engineering. Evolution and process on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Proceedings of the 6th international conference on software engineering, 1982. Lecture 2 software reengineering university of toronto. From architecture to source code how to ensure architecture compliance in the implemented system1 1 this work was performed as part of the project arque architecturecentric quality engineering, which is partially. Bridging the gap between design and implementation. Week 5 429 mon 51 wed hoare logic and weakest precondition software verification quiz 2 429 monday week 6. Success requires an integrated approach across departments. Practice and experience on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Intensional views are logic rules that ensure rules.
To mitigate this, a set of guidelines and tools may be developed to assist a valueconscious adoption of design practices. Each entry contained the name of the calling function, the name of the called function, and the file and directory information for both functions. For some software engineering tasks, sourcelevel information is not optimal because there is a wide gap between the information presented i. Proceedings of the 3rd acm sigsoft symposium on foundations of software engineering, pages 1828, new york, ny, usa, 1995.
Threat modeling is a lightweight approach to reason about application security and uses data flow diagrams dfds with security annotations. With this paradigm shift, the systems architecture is defined by an autosar model that is used for. Because a systems software architecture strongly influences its quality attributes such as modifiability, performance, and security, it is important to analyze and reason about that architecture. The goal of conceptual integrity or unity of design. Software designs tend to deteriorate over time and there is a need for tools and techniques that support software architects when dealing with legacy systems. This issue grows to bigger dimension with the presence of cloud computing. Jan 22, 20 in user experience design, interaction design and in humancomputer interaction in general, three model types are especially important. Us 8,584,099 b1 page 2 56 references cited other publications lam, patrick, et al. An implementation model is a representation of how a system application, service, interface etc. Here are some lessons on the things to consider while taking a programme from research to reality. Murphy, david notkin, and kevin sullivan, software reflexion models. Bridging the gap between design and implementation by gail murphy et al.
Mike pagel is software architect for body electronics at bmw group in munich germany. I will generally try to be available for 1015 minutes before class, try to stick around after for questions, to answer email, and to take calls about the course 2066853798. In companion to the 19th annual acm sigplan conference on objectoriented programming. Acm transactions on software engineering and methodology, 161. Php, 65 kloc it is an parallel implementation of the media shop, an information system example in goaloriented requirements engineering it has been studied by clone detection we want to show the connection of goal models with aspect elicitation. Autosar architecture automatic checking of implementation conformance the autosarbased development methodology is increasingly applied during software development for the volume production. We have developed the software reflexion model technique to help engineers perform various software engineering tasks by exploiting, rather than removing, the drift between design and. Reflexion modelling is considered one of the more successful approaches to architecture reconciliation. Bridging the gap between software and hardware techniques for io virtualization jose renato santos yoshio turner g. Design, implementation, and evaluation of a revision control system. Three static architecture compliance checking approaches a comparison1 1 this work was performed in the project arque architecturecentric quality engineering which is partially funded by the german ministry of education and research bmbf under grant number 01is f14. The structure and value of modularity in software design. Towards controlling software architecture erosion through.
An approach to managing the architecture of large software systems is presented. We have developed the software reflexion model technique to help engineers perform various software engineering tasks by exploiting rather than removing the drift between design and implementation. Design erosion is a persistent problem within the software engineering discipline. Understanding software systems using reverse engineering technology. A variety of algorithms are available to help organize the matrix in a form that reflects the architecture and highlights patterns and problematic dependencies. In the proceedings of the third acm sigsoft symposium on the. In addition, it is rare that software development begins. Murphy, david notkin, kevin sullivan sigsoft 95 proceedings of the 3rd acm sigsoft symposium on foundations of software engineering, 1995. Three static architecture compliance checking approaches a. More specifically, the technique helps an engineer compare artifacts by summarizing where one artifact such as a design is consistent with and inconsistent with another artifact such as source.
Bridging the gap between source and highlevel models. Pdf using dependency models to manage complex software. We extended reflexion models to check the conformance of an asdesigned dfd with an approximation of the asbuilt dfd obtained from the implementation. The software architecture of a system is often used to guide and constrain its implementation. Ian pratt hewlett packard laboratories, palo alto, ca.
Reflexion model jrmtool highlevel model hlm multigraph source model sm multigraph source code or trace. Design with intensional views a case study, journal of computer languages, systems and structures, vol. Using dependency models to manage complex software. He is best known for his work with ultralargescale uls systems. Implementation, mental and representation models in user. Read assessing architectural drift in commercial software development.
Incremental reflexion analysis, journal of software. Bridge pattern bridging the gap between interface and. Article pdf available in ieee transactions on software engineering. A software rejlexion model is then computed to determine where the engineers highlevel model does and does not agree wit h the source model. Bridging the gap between design and implementation by murphy, g. The artifacts constituting a software system often drift apart over time. The paper provides a formal characterization of reflexion models, discusses practical aspects of the approach, and relates experiences of applying the approach and tools to a number. Sullivan is an american associate professor of computer science at the university of virginia in charlottesville, virginia, united states. However, architectural documentation frequently does not exist, and when it does, it is often out of sync with the implemented system. Ieee computer society transactions on software engineering, 27 4, 364380.
Architectural drift analysis using architecture reflexion. Read incremental reflexion analysis, journal of software. Bridging the gap between decision making and implementation. Murphy, david notkin, kevin sullivan ieee transactions on software engineering, 1995. An empirical study using task assignment patterns to improve the accuracy of software effort estimation. Jan 01, 2011 read assessing architectural drift in commercial software development. Design and implementation of a vbr continuous media file server. Dependencies are extracted from the code by a conventional static analysis, and shown in a tabular form known as the dependency structure matrix dsm. Assessing architectural drift in commercial software. The 8th joint meeting of the european software engineering conference esec and the acm sigsoft symposium on the foundations of software engineering fse, 2011. Mns95 presented an approach for bridging the gap between program code elements and higherlevel software models. From architecture to source code how to ensure architecture. For example, this rule ensures that the argument of an accept method is named after the class it should be accepted. Extending the reflexion method for consolidating software.
We have developed the software reflexion model technique to help engineers perform various software engineering tasks by exploiting, rather than removing, the drift between design and implementation. Proceedings of the 28th international conference on software engineering. Three static architecture compliance checking approaches. In proceedings of the 2009 ieee 31st international conference on software engineering may 16 24, 2009. Empirical studies strongly suggest that professional developers involved in reallife industrial projects find the information provided by variants of this approach useful and insightful, but the degree to which it resolves architecture conformance issues is still unclear.
Moreover, the gap between the design and the implementation of software has always been a major challenge in software devel opment 34, which also affects the adoption of design practices. Acm sigsoft software engineering notesoctober 1995. A popular approach for coping with this problem is reflexion modeling which usually compares an abstract model of the code with the architecture model. Bridging the gap between design and implementation gc murphy, d notkin, kj sullivan ieee transactions on software engineering 27 4, 364380, 2001. From architecture to source code how to ensure architecture compliance in the implemented system1 1 this work was performed as part of the project arque architecturecentric quality engineering, which is partially funded by the german ministry of education and research bmbf under grant number 01 is f14. Differences between architecture views implementation does not follow the architecture. Decoupling abstraction from implementation inheritance tightly couples an abstraction with an implementation at compile time.
While the code structure of an initial implementation is likely to conform to its intended architecture, its dynamic properties cannot always be fully checked until deployment. Quality concerns in largescale and complex software. Reflexion model jrmtool highlevel model hlm multigraph. Efficient mapping of software system traces to architectural. Undergraduate level knowledge of data structures and objectoriented program languages is required. Bridging the gap between source and highlevel models, in symposium on the foundations of software.
Home sigs sigsoft acm sigsoft software engineering notes vol. Bridging the gap between design and implementation of. He also holds the title of virginia engineering foundation vef endowed faculty fellow in computer science at the university of virginia. Sullivan, senior member, ieee abstractthe artifacts constituting a software system often drift apart over time. Bridging the gap between source and highlevel models, proceedings of the third acm sigsoft symposium on foundations of software engineering, washington, dc, october 10, pp. Objectoriented design is usually driven by three main reusability principles. Acm sigsoft impact paper award acm special interest.
The best programs and software systems exhibit a sense of. Bridging the gap between source and highlevel models by gail c. Bridging the gap between software and hardware techniques for. The thresholds may vary considerably depending on software size, cost, nature of team, software process being used, software quality framework being used, and so on. This class is intended to introduce current research topics in software engineering with focus on software evolution. Bridging the gap between design and implementation gail c. Bridging the gap between design and implementation stages has been a major concern that deplores designers, analysts and developers for quite a long time during the design and implementation of information systems in traditional environments. A mechanism for specifying the structure of large, layered. Assessing the evidence from change management data mining version histories to guide software changes software reflexion models. Bridging the gap between design and implementation 365 fig. This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar.
329 174 1256 628 1644 27 258 943 903 29 124 1085 1519 853 145 331 319 312 1048 1659 634 492 417 1571 1608 1551 1691 477 1359 323 1295 1065 948 1224 1194 1313 1420 1424